How to critique.

Commenting on other people's creations is a nice way to let someone know what you think of their work so that they can improve what they do. Before "critiquing", it's probably a good idea to keep reading.

I. What NOT to do

It's highly recommend that you all read the Dimpleton Rules before attempting to post anything on these forums. When it comes to critiquing, I will evoke two of those rules in particular.

It's important to note that telling people that their work is amazing when it's terrible is harmful to a person's progression and will just make a bad critique come as more of a shock.
Whilst being honest, there are methods of conveying a concept that do not result in being nasty. "The truth hurts", but there's no need to put salt in the wound.

II. Objective vs. Subjective

Here are two examples of very similar comments about someone's work:

What's the difference? Well it's rather important. The first comment is formed as that of a fact making it seem objective and the absolute truth. Whilst the second one starts off with something along the lines of "In my opinion" to show that it really only is the opinion of someone, is Subjective and therefore should not be taken as the absolute truth but as a mere opinion.

Voicing your opinion about something whilst making sure that it is understood as only your opinion is vital.

III. Suggested things to do

Here's a short list of a couple of handy things to keep in mind whilst commenting on someone's work:

• Be honest, but keep it appropriate.

• Make sure you show that it's your opinion.

• Outline in a simple form what is wrong.

• Include the details on what is needed to improve the work in question.

Optional:

• Provide useful information on how to improve as an artist.